VRCWiki:Conflicts of interest - Revision history

Usr 2c0d9735-9342-4db3-9c48-5eb152581b08: Add English Original Rules

2025-10-27T23:41:19Z

Add English Original Rules

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:41, 27 October 2025
Line 1:		Line 1:
			{{Noticebox/Guidelines_translation}}
	<languages/>		<languages/>
	<translate>		<translate>

Usr c0fd3826-5fbd-465b-869b-142f974af714: Added policy navbox & added `around a copy+paste string.`


2025-08-19T02:02:17Z
Added policy navbox & added <code> around a copy+paste string.

				
				
				
				
				
				← Older revision
				Revision as of 02:02, 19 August 2025
				
Line 80:
Line 80:



<!--T:19--> <!--T:19-->
It can be added to to an article using the following text: <nowiki>{{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}}</nowiki> It can be added to to an article using the following text: <code><nowiki>{{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}}</nowiki></code>
</translate> </translate>
<translate> <translate>
Line 89:
Line 89:
</translate> </translate>
[[Category:VRCWiki policies{{#translation:}}]] [[Category:VRCWiki policies{{#translation:}}]]

----
{{Navbox/Wiki_policies}}



Usr 2c0d9735-9342-4db3-9c48-5eb152581b08: Changed protection settings for "VRCWiki:Conflicts of interest": changed back ([Edit=Allow only administrators] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite))
2025-01-13T01:17:28Z
Changed protection settings for "VRCWiki:Conflicts of interest": changed back ([Edit=Allow only administrators] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite))

				
				← Older revision
				Revision as of 01:17, 13 January 2025
				
(No difference)



Usr 2c0d9735-9342-4db3-9c48-5eb152581b08: Marked this version for translation
2025-01-13T01:16:05Z
Marked this version for translation

				
				
				
				
				
				← Older revision
				Revision as of 01:16, 13 January 2025
				
Line 1:
Line 1:
<languages/> <languages/>
<translate> <translate>
<!--T:1-->
'''Conflict of Interest (COI)''' occurs when an individual has significant affiliations with a project, such as a [[Special:MyLanguage/Worlds|World]], Avatar, Prefab, or Community. COI editing refers to the practice of someone closely associated with a project creating or making substantial edits to a page about that project. '''Conflict of Interest (COI)''' occurs when an individual has significant affiliations with a project, such as a [[Special:MyLanguage/Worlds|World]], Avatar, Prefab, or Community. COI editing refers to the practice of someone closely associated with a project creating or making substantial edits to a page about that project.



<!--T:2-->
Conflict of Interest is best understood not as a standalone policy but as part of the broader framework of general editor guidelines, alongside principles like [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Notability|Notability]], [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Neutral point of view|Neutral Point of View (NPOV)]], and [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research|No Original Research (NOR)]]. COI policies work in conjunction with these guidelines to preemptively avoid potential issues before any edits are made. For instance, Notability cannot be self-established, and COI policies reinforce this by preventing individuals or organizations from establishing the Notability of their own projects through page creation. Conflict of Interest is best understood not as a standalone policy but as part of the broader framework of general editor guidelines, alongside principles like [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Notability|Notability]], [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Neutral point of view|Neutral Point of View (NPOV)]], and [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research|No Original Research (NOR)]]. COI policies work in conjunction with these guidelines to preemptively avoid potential issues before any edits are made. For instance, Notability cannot be self-established, and COI policies reinforce this by preventing individuals or organizations from establishing the Notability of their own projects through page creation.



<!--T:3-->
It is not assumed that an editor with a COI would create or edit a page with the intention of advertising. However, an editor with a COI is inherently more likely to embellish information, selectively curate content, or [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research|treat the page as a primary source]]. It is not assumed that an editor with a COI would create or edit a page with the intention of advertising. However, an editor with a COI is inherently more likely to embellish information, selectively curate content, or [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research|treat the page as a primary source]].
</translate> </translate>
<translate> <translate>
<!--T:4-->
== Examples == == Examples ==
Here are some examples of situations where you would have a Conflict of Interest for a given project: Here are some examples of situations where you would have a Conflict of Interest for a given project:



<!--T:5-->
* You created the project. * You created the project.
* You were involved in developing, moderating, or facilitating the project in any tangible way. * You were involved in developing, moderating, or facilitating the project in any tangible way.
Line 16:
Line 21:
</translate> </translate>
<translate> <translate>
<!--T:6-->
== Policies == == Policies ==
The VRChat Wiki enforces '''two core policies''' regarding Conflict of Interest editing: The VRChat Wiki enforces '''two core policies''' regarding Conflict of Interest editing:



<!--T:7-->
# '''Restrictions on Editing''': Editors who have created a project or made significant contributions to it are strictly prohibited from creating pages about that project. Editors with a substantial COI are limited to making only [[wikipedia:Help:Minor_edit|minor edits]] on pages related to the project. # '''Restrictions on Editing''': Editors who have created a project or made significant contributions to it are strictly prohibited from creating pages about that project. Editors with a substantial COI are limited to making only [[wikipedia:Help:Minor_edit|minor edits]] on pages related to the project.
# '''Enforcement and Consequences''': Pages created in violation of these policies are subject to immediate deletion, with the author being notified through appropriate channels, such as their talk page or Discord (if applicable). # '''Enforcement and Consequences''': Pages created in violation of these policies are subject to immediate deletion, with the author being notified through appropriate channels, such as their talk page or Discord (if applicable).
</translate> </translate>
<translate> <translate>
<!--T:8-->
== Situations that are ''NOT'' (necessarily) Conflicts of Interest == == Situations that are ''NOT'' (necessarily) Conflicts of Interest ==
Conflict of Interest is not always a clear-cut, binary concept but rather a spectrum of proximity and involvement. When an editor with even a slight affiliation to a project considers their potential COI, it is generally wise to err on the side of caution and assume a COI exists to avoid any potential conflicts. However, there are many situations where someone with a potential COI can still make constructive major edits to a project's page, depending on various factors. Conflict of Interest is not always a clear-cut, binary concept but rather a spectrum of proximity and involvement. When an editor with even a slight affiliation to a project considers their potential COI, it is generally wise to err on the side of caution and assume a COI exists to avoid any potential conflicts. However, there are many situations where someone with a potential COI can still make constructive major edits to a project's page, depending on various factors.



<!--T:9-->
A useful way to evaluate your potential COI is by considering how easily you could disengage from your affiliation. Simply put, if it's easy for you to "leave" without any impact, your COI is likely minimal. If your involvement is embedded in the project's development or maintenance, then you certainly have a COI. A useful way to evaluate your potential COI is by considering how easily you could disengage from your affiliation. Simply put, if it's easy for you to "leave" without any impact, your COI is likely minimal. If your involvement is embedded in the project's development or maintenance, then you certainly have a COI.



<!--T:10-->
In all cases, editors who believe they may have even a minor COI should disclose the details in the edit summary and ensure their contributions adhere strictly to editing guidelines, particularly regarding Neutral Point of View (NPOV). In all cases, editors who believe they may have even a minor COI should disclose the details in the edit summary and ensure their contributions adhere strictly to editing guidelines, particularly regarding Neutral Point of View (NPOV).



<!--T:11-->
Here are some examples, roughly ordered from most to least significant COI: Here are some examples, roughly ordered from most to least significant COI:



<!--T:12-->
==== Having a personal relationship with someone affiliated with a project ==== ==== Having a personal relationship with someone affiliated with a project ====
This situation is difficult to define precisely, as it ranges from "close romantic relationships" to "casual acquaintances on social media." Only you can fully assess the extent of your relationship and determine whether you can or should ethically contribute to the project's page. This is the most sensitive case, requiring careful consideration. This situation is difficult to define precisely, as it ranges from "close romantic relationships" to "casual acquaintances on social media." Only you can fully assess the extent of your relationship and determine whether you can or should ethically contribute to the project's page. This is the most sensitive case, requiring careful consideration.



<!--T:13-->
==== Being a Patreon subscriber, or having made other financial contributions to a project ==== ==== Being a Patreon subscriber, or having made other financial contributions to a project ====
While financial support for a project reflects a strong interest, it does not necessarily indicate a deep affiliation and can be withdrawn at any time. Although financial supporters may lean toward positive phrasing, they are still independent from the project itself and may not share the same views as those actively involved in creating or sustaining it. Disclosure is recommended, but financial support alone is not a definitive COI. While financial support for a project reflects a strong interest, it does not necessarily indicate a deep affiliation and can be withdrawn at any time. Although financial supporters may lean toward positive phrasing, they are still independent from the project itself and may not share the same views as those actively involved in creating or sustaining it. Disclosure is recommended, but financial support alone is not a definitive COI.



<!--T:14-->
==== Being a member of a community ==== ==== Being a member of a community ====
This is similar to the case of financial contributors, but with even more independence and flexibility. Community involvement can vary widely, from contributing content and attending events to simply lurking in a Discord server. While these activities fall at different points on the COI spectrum, they are generally of low concern as long as the standard guidelines are followed. This is similar to the case of financial contributors, but with even more independence and flexibility. Community involvement can vary widely, from contributing content and attending events to simply lurking in a Discord server. While these activities fall at different points on the COI spectrum, they are generally of low concern as long as the standard guidelines are followed.



<!--T:15-->
==== Having a strong interest in a project ==== ==== Having a strong interest in a project ====
Having a general interest in a topic or project is '''not considered a COI and is, in fact, encouraged'''! The Wiki is built on contributions from volunteers who share their time and expertise. While we value those who contribute to any page that needs it, we also encourage editors to focus on topics they are passionate about, as long as they do so in a responsible and balanced manner. Having a general interest in a topic or project is '''not considered a COI and is, in fact, encouraged'''! The Wiki is built on contributions from volunteers who share their time and expertise. While we value those who contribute to any page that needs it, we also encourage editors to focus on topics they are passionate about, as long as they do so in a responsible and balanced manner.
</translate> </translate>
<translate> <translate>
<!--T:16-->
== A general example that summarizes it all: == == A general example that summarizes it all: ==
Let's assume a hypothetical project in the form of a World called "'''Super Fun World'''". Let's assume a hypothetical project in the form of a World called "'''Super Fun World'''".
Line 55:
Line 71:
</translate> </translate>
<translate> <translate>
<!--T:17-->
==Conflict of Interest noticebox== ==Conflict of Interest noticebox==
If an article primarily (or entirely) contains content written by someone with a '''partial''' Conflict of Interest, it will be displayed with the following noticebox: If an article primarily (or entirely) contains content written by someone with a '''partial''' Conflict of Interest, it will be displayed with the following noticebox:
{{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}} {{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}}



<!--T:18-->
Note, this '''cannot''' be used to circumvent the two fundamental policies. Any pages found to have been created in violation of them, ''even if they contain this noticebox'', will still be eligible for deletion. Note, this '''cannot''' be used to circumvent the two fundamental policies. Any pages found to have been created in violation of them, ''even if they contain this noticebox'', will still be eligible for deletion.



<!--T:19-->
It can be added to to an article using the following text: <nowiki>{{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}}</nowiki> It can be added to to an article using the following text: <nowiki>{{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}}</nowiki>
</translate> </translate>
<translate> <translate>
<!--T:20-->
==See also== ==See also==
* [[VRCWiki:Guidelines|VRCWiki:Guidelines]] * [[VRCWiki:Guidelines|VRCWiki:Guidelines]]



Usr 2c0d9735-9342-4db3-9c48-5eb152581b08: Fix group
2025-01-13T01:13:19Z
Fix group

				
				
				
				
				
				← Older revision
				Revision as of 01:13, 13 January 2025
				
Line 2:
Line 2:
<translate> <translate>
'''Conflict of Interest (COI)''' occurs when an individual has significant affiliations with a project, such as a [[Special:MyLanguage/Worlds|World]], Avatar, Prefab, or Community. COI editing refers to the practice of someone closely associated with a project creating or making substantial edits to a page about that project. '''Conflict of Interest (COI)''' occurs when an individual has significant affiliations with a project, such as a [[Special:MyLanguage/Worlds|World]], Avatar, Prefab, or Community. COI editing refers to the practice of someone closely associated with a project creating or making substantial edits to a page about that project.
</translate>  
<translate> 
Conflict of Interest is best understood not as a standalone policy but as part of the broader framework of general editor guidelines, alongside principles like [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Notability|Notability]], [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Neutral point of view|Neutral Point of View (NPOV)]], and [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research|No Original Research (NOR)]]. COI policies work in conjunction with these guidelines to preemptively avoid potential issues before any edits are made. For instance, Notability cannot be self-established, and COI policies reinforce this by preventing individuals or organizations from establishing the Notability of their own projects through page creation. Conflict of Interest is best understood not as a standalone policy but as part of the broader framework of general editor guidelines, alongside principles like [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Notability|Notability]], [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Neutral point of view|Neutral Point of View (NPOV)]], and [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research|No Original Research (NOR)]]. COI policies work in conjunction with these guidelines to preemptively avoid potential issues before any edits are made. For instance, Notability cannot be self-established, and COI policies reinforce this by preventing individuals or organizations from establishing the Notability of their own projects through page creation.






Usr 2c0d9735-9342-4db3-9c48-5eb152581b08: Mark for Translation
2025-01-13T01:12:00Z
Mark for Translation

				
				
				
				
				
				← Older revision
				Revision as of 01:12, 13 January 2025
				
Line 1:
Line 1:
'''Conflict of Interest (COI)''' occurs when an individual has significant affiliations with a project, such as a [[Worlds|World]], Avatar, Prefab, or Community. COI editing refers to the practice of someone closely associated with a project creating or making substantial edits to a page about that project. <languages/>
  <translate>
Conflict of Interest is best understood not as a standalone policy but as part of the broader framework of general editor guidelines, alongside principles like [[VRCWiki:Notability|Notability]], [[VRCWiki:Neutral point of view|Neutral Point of View (NPOV)]], and [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research|No Original Research (NOR)]]. COI policies work in conjunction with these guidelines to preemptively avoid potential issues before any edits are made. For instance, Notability cannot be self-established, and COI policies reinforce this by preventing individuals or organizations from establishing the Notability of their own projects through page creation. '''Conflict of Interest (COI)''' occurs when an individual has significant affiliations with a project, such as a [[Special:MyLanguage/Worlds|World]], Avatar, Prefab, or Community. COI editing refers to the practice of someone closely associated with a project creating or making substantial edits to a page about that project.
</translate>
<translate>
Conflict of Interest is best understood not as a standalone policy but as part of the broader framework of general editor guidelines, alongside principles like [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Notability|Notability]], [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Neutral point of view|Neutral Point of View (NPOV)]], and [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research|No Original Research (NOR)]]. COI policies work in conjunction with these guidelines to preemptively avoid potential issues before any edits are made. For instance, Notability cannot be self-established, and COI policies reinforce this by preventing individuals or organizations from establishing the Notability of their own projects through page creation.



It is not assumed that an editor with a COI would create or edit a page with the intention of advertising. However, an editor with a COI is inherently more likely to embellish information, selectively curate content, or [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research|treat the page as a primary source]]. It is not assumed that an editor with a COI would create or edit a page with the intention of advertising. However, an editor with a COI is inherently more likely to embellish information, selectively curate content, or [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research|treat the page as a primary source]].
  </translate>
<translate>
== Examples == == Examples ==
Here are some examples of situations where you would have a Conflict of Interest for a given project: Here are some examples of situations where you would have a Conflict of Interest for a given project:
Line 11:
Line 15:
* You were involved in developing, moderating, or facilitating the project in any tangible way. * You were involved in developing, moderating, or facilitating the project in any tangible way.
* You were the sole or initial financial backer of the project (e.g., commissioning the project). * You were the sole or initial financial backer of the project (e.g., commissioning the project).
  </translate>
<translate>
== Policies == == Policies ==
The VRChat Wiki enforces '''two core policies''' regarding Conflict of Interest editing: The VRChat Wiki enforces '''two core policies''' regarding Conflict of Interest editing:
Line 17:
Line 22:
# '''Restrictions on Editing''': Editors who have created a project or made significant contributions to it are strictly prohibited from creating pages about that project. Editors with a substantial COI are limited to making only [[wikipedia:Help:Minor_edit|minor edits]] on pages related to the project. # '''Restrictions on Editing''': Editors who have created a project or made significant contributions to it are strictly prohibited from creating pages about that project. Editors with a substantial COI are limited to making only [[wikipedia:Help:Minor_edit|minor edits]] on pages related to the project.
# '''Enforcement and Consequences''': Pages created in violation of these policies are subject to immediate deletion, with the author being notified through appropriate channels, such as their talk page or Discord (if applicable). # '''Enforcement and Consequences''': Pages created in violation of these policies are subject to immediate deletion, with the author being notified through appropriate channels, such as their talk page or Discord (if applicable).
  </translate>
<translate>
== Situations that are ''NOT'' (necessarily) Conflicts of Interest == == Situations that are ''NOT'' (necessarily) Conflicts of Interest ==
Conflict of Interest is not always a clear-cut, binary concept but rather a spectrum of proximity and involvement. When an editor with even a slight affiliation to a project considers their potential COI, it is generally wise to err on the side of caution and assume a COI exists to avoid any potential conflicts. However, there are many situations where someone with a potential COI can still make constructive major edits to a project's page, depending on various factors. Conflict of Interest is not always a clear-cut, binary concept but rather a spectrum of proximity and involvement. When an editor with even a slight affiliation to a project considers their potential COI, it is generally wise to err on the side of caution and assume a COI exists to avoid any potential conflicts. However, there are many situations where someone with a potential COI can still make constructive major edits to a project's page, depending on various factors.
Line 38:
Line 44:
==== Having a strong interest in a project ==== ==== Having a strong interest in a project ====
Having a general interest in a topic or project is '''not considered a COI and is, in fact, encouraged'''! The Wiki is built on contributions from volunteers who share their time and expertise. While we value those who contribute to any page that needs it, we also encourage editors to focus on topics they are passionate about, as long as they do so in a responsible and balanced manner. Having a general interest in a topic or project is '''not considered a COI and is, in fact, encouraged'''! The Wiki is built on contributions from volunteers who share their time and expertise. While we value those who contribute to any page that needs it, we also encourage editors to focus on topics they are passionate about, as long as they do so in a responsible and balanced manner.
  </translate>
<translate>
== A general example that summarizes it all: == == A general example that summarizes it all: ==
Let's assume a hypothetical project in the form of a World called "'''Super Fun World'''". Let's assume a hypothetical project in the form of a World called "'''Super Fun World'''".
Line 47:
Line 54:
* A '''hardcore fan''' of Super Fun World reads a new development blog published by the creator and decides some of the information is notable enough to include in the article. They add a new section (or update an existing one) with a neutral point of view, using the blog as a citation. * A '''hardcore fan''' of Super Fun World reads a new development blog published by the creator and decides some of the information is notable enough to include in the article. They add a new section (or update an existing one) with a neutral point of view, using the blog as a citation.
…and so on! This example illustrates how different levels of affiliation affect editing practices while ensuring adherence to COI guidelines. …and so on! This example illustrates how different levels of affiliation affect editing practices while ensuring adherence to COI guidelines.
  </translate>
<translate>
==Conflict of Interest noticebox== ==Conflict of Interest noticebox==
If an article primarily (or entirely) contains content written by someone with a '''partial''' Conflict of Interest, it will be displayed with the following noticebox: If an article primarily (or entirely) contains content written by someone with a '''partial''' Conflict of Interest, it will be displayed with the following noticebox:
Line 55:
Line 63:



It can be added to to an article using the following text: <nowiki>{{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}}</nowiki> It can be added to to an article using the following text: <nowiki>{{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}}</nowiki>
  </translate>
<translate>
==See also== ==See also==
* [[VRCWiki:Guidelines]] * [[VRCWiki:Guidelines|VRCWiki:Guidelines]]
* [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Conflict_of_interest Wikipedia:Conflict of interest] on Wikipedia * [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Conflict_of_interest Wikipedia:Conflict of interest] on Wikipedia
  </translate>
[[Category:VRCWiki policies]] [[Category:VRCWiki policies{{#translation:}}]]



Usr 2c0d9735-9342-4db3-9c48-5eb152581b08: Changed protection settings for "VRCWiki:Conflicts of interest": temp change to mark for translation ([Edit=Allow only autoconfirmed users] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only autoconfirmed users] (indefinite))
2025-01-13T01:11:48Z
Changed protection settings for "VRCWiki:Conflicts of interest": temp change to mark for translation ([Edit=Allow only autoconfirmed users] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only autoconfirmed users] (indefinite))

				
				← Older revision
				Revision as of 01:11, 13 January 2025
				
(No difference)



Usr 578aa632-439b-4c41-9266-776323ba9ad2: de-tableify wording while maintaining intent (needs proofread!)
2024-10-11T15:41:30Z
de-tableify wording while maintaining intent (needs proofread!)
Show changes


Usr edc96730-b899-466c-b373-34e59e839444: Full COI policy re-write, courtesy of months of discussion and several meetings worth of discussions giving me a general idea of what I should write and cover for examples. I have more to write, but this should suffice for now and it's been like 5 hours since I started drafting this and I'm getting kinda tired 🥴
2024-10-08T19:38:31Z
Full COI policy re-write, courtesy of months of discussion and several meetings worth of discussions giving me a general idea of what I should write and cover for examples. I have more to write, but this should suffice for now and it's been like 5 hours since I started drafting this and I'm getting kinda tired 🥴
Show changes


Usr c272d4fe-f1f8-4d77-8008-cad6cb81d6cd: Protected "VRCWiki:Conflicts of interest": High-risk template or module: This is a VRCWiki policy page and should not be edited by regular editors. ([Edit=Allow only administrators] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite))
2024-10-08T17:51:42Z
Protected "VRCWiki:Conflicts of interest": High-risk template or module: This is a VRCWiki policy page and should not be edited by regular editors. ([Edit=Allow only administrators] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite))

				
				← Older revision
				Revision as of 17:51, 8 October 2024
				
(No difference)

← Older revision		Revision as of 02:02, 19 August 2025
Line 80:		Line 80:

	<!--T:19-->		<!--T:19-->
	It can be added to to an article using the following text: <nowiki>{{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}}</nowiki>		It can be added to to an article using the following text: <code><nowiki>{{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}}</nowiki></code>
	</translate>		</translate>
	<translate>		<translate>
Line 89:		Line 89:
	</translate>		</translate>
	[[Category:VRCWiki policies{{#translation:}}]]		[[Category:VRCWiki policies{{#translation:}}]]

			----
			{{Navbox/Wiki_policies}}

← Older revision	Revision as of 01:17, 13 January 2025
(No difference)

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:16, 13 January 2025
Line 1:		Line 1:
	<languages/>		<languages/>
	<translate>		<translate>
			<!--T:1-->
	'''Conflict of Interest (COI)''' occurs when an individual has significant affiliations with a project, such as a [[Special:MyLanguage/Worlds\|World]], Avatar, Prefab, or Community. COI editing refers to the practice of someone closely associated with a project creating or making substantial edits to a page about that project.		'''Conflict of Interest (COI)''' occurs when an individual has significant affiliations with a project, such as a [[Special:MyLanguage/Worlds\|World]], Avatar, Prefab, or Community. COI editing refers to the practice of someone closely associated with a project creating or making substantial edits to a page about that project.

			<!--T:2-->
	Conflict of Interest is best understood not as a standalone policy but as part of the broader framework of general editor guidelines, alongside principles like [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Notability\|Notability]], [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Neutral point of view\|Neutral Point of View (NPOV)]], and [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research\|No Original Research (NOR)]]. COI policies work in conjunction with these guidelines to preemptively avoid potential issues before any edits are made. For instance, Notability cannot be self-established, and COI policies reinforce this by preventing individuals or organizations from establishing the Notability of their own projects through page creation.		Conflict of Interest is best understood not as a standalone policy but as part of the broader framework of general editor guidelines, alongside principles like [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Notability\|Notability]], [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Neutral point of view\|Neutral Point of View (NPOV)]], and [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research\|No Original Research (NOR)]]. COI policies work in conjunction with these guidelines to preemptively avoid potential issues before any edits are made. For instance, Notability cannot be self-established, and COI policies reinforce this by preventing individuals or organizations from establishing the Notability of their own projects through page creation.

			<!--T:3-->
	It is not assumed that an editor with a COI would create or edit a page with the intention of advertising. However, an editor with a COI is inherently more likely to embellish information, selectively curate content, or [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research\|treat the page as a primary source]].		It is not assumed that an editor with a COI would create or edit a page with the intention of advertising. However, an editor with a COI is inherently more likely to embellish information, selectively curate content, or [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research\|treat the page as a primary source]].
	</translate>		</translate>
	<translate>		<translate>
			<!--T:4-->
	== Examples ==		== Examples ==
	Here are some examples of situations where you would have a Conflict of Interest for a given project:		Here are some examples of situations where you would have a Conflict of Interest for a given project:

			<!--T:5-->
	* You created the project.		* You created the project.
	* You were involved in developing, moderating, or facilitating the project in any tangible way.		* You were involved in developing, moderating, or facilitating the project in any tangible way.
Line 16:		Line 21:
	</translate>		</translate>
	<translate>		<translate>
			<!--T:6-->
	== Policies ==		== Policies ==
	The VRChat Wiki enforces '''two core policies''' regarding Conflict of Interest editing:		The VRChat Wiki enforces '''two core policies''' regarding Conflict of Interest editing:

			<!--T:7-->
	# '''Restrictions on Editing''': Editors who have created a project or made significant contributions to it are strictly prohibited from creating pages about that project. Editors with a substantial COI are limited to making only [[wikipedia:Help:Minor_edit\|minor edits]] on pages related to the project.		# '''Restrictions on Editing''': Editors who have created a project or made significant contributions to it are strictly prohibited from creating pages about that project. Editors with a substantial COI are limited to making only [[wikipedia:Help:Minor_edit\|minor edits]] on pages related to the project.
	# '''Enforcement and Consequences''': Pages created in violation of these policies are subject to immediate deletion, with the author being notified through appropriate channels, such as their talk page or Discord (if applicable).		# '''Enforcement and Consequences''': Pages created in violation of these policies are subject to immediate deletion, with the author being notified through appropriate channels, such as their talk page or Discord (if applicable).
	</translate>		</translate>
	<translate>		<translate>
			<!--T:8-->
	== Situations that are ''NOT'' (necessarily) Conflicts of Interest ==		== Situations that are ''NOT'' (necessarily) Conflicts of Interest ==
	Conflict of Interest is not always a clear-cut, binary concept but rather a spectrum of proximity and involvement. When an editor with even a slight affiliation to a project considers their potential COI, it is generally wise to err on the side of caution and assume a COI exists to avoid any potential conflicts. However, there are many situations where someone with a potential COI can still make constructive major edits to a project's page, depending on various factors.		Conflict of Interest is not always a clear-cut, binary concept but rather a spectrum of proximity and involvement. When an editor with even a slight affiliation to a project considers their potential COI, it is generally wise to err on the side of caution and assume a COI exists to avoid any potential conflicts. However, there are many situations where someone with a potential COI can still make constructive major edits to a project's page, depending on various factors.

			<!--T:9-->
	A useful way to evaluate your potential COI is by considering how easily you could disengage from your affiliation. Simply put, if it's easy for you to "leave" without any impact, your COI is likely minimal. If your involvement is embedded in the project's development or maintenance, then you certainly have a COI.		A useful way to evaluate your potential COI is by considering how easily you could disengage from your affiliation. Simply put, if it's easy for you to "leave" without any impact, your COI is likely minimal. If your involvement is embedded in the project's development or maintenance, then you certainly have a COI.

			<!--T:10-->
	In all cases, editors who believe they may have even a minor COI should disclose the details in the edit summary and ensure their contributions adhere strictly to editing guidelines, particularly regarding Neutral Point of View (NPOV).		In all cases, editors who believe they may have even a minor COI should disclose the details in the edit summary and ensure their contributions adhere strictly to editing guidelines, particularly regarding Neutral Point of View (NPOV).

			<!--T:11-->
	Here are some examples, roughly ordered from most to least significant COI:		Here are some examples, roughly ordered from most to least significant COI:

			<!--T:12-->
	==== Having a personal relationship with someone affiliated with a project ====		==== Having a personal relationship with someone affiliated with a project ====
	This situation is difficult to define precisely, as it ranges from "close romantic relationships" to "casual acquaintances on social media." Only you can fully assess the extent of your relationship and determine whether you can or should ethically contribute to the project's page. This is the most sensitive case, requiring careful consideration.		This situation is difficult to define precisely, as it ranges from "close romantic relationships" to "casual acquaintances on social media." Only you can fully assess the extent of your relationship and determine whether you can or should ethically contribute to the project's page. This is the most sensitive case, requiring careful consideration.

			<!--T:13-->
	==== Being a Patreon subscriber, or having made other financial contributions to a project ====		==== Being a Patreon subscriber, or having made other financial contributions to a project ====
	While financial support for a project reflects a strong interest, it does not necessarily indicate a deep affiliation and can be withdrawn at any time. Although financial supporters may lean toward positive phrasing, they are still independent from the project itself and may not share the same views as those actively involved in creating or sustaining it. Disclosure is recommended, but financial support alone is not a definitive COI.		While financial support for a project reflects a strong interest, it does not necessarily indicate a deep affiliation and can be withdrawn at any time. Although financial supporters may lean toward positive phrasing, they are still independent from the project itself and may not share the same views as those actively involved in creating or sustaining it. Disclosure is recommended, but financial support alone is not a definitive COI.

			<!--T:14-->
	==== Being a member of a community ====		==== Being a member of a community ====
	This is similar to the case of financial contributors, but with even more independence and flexibility. Community involvement can vary widely, from contributing content and attending events to simply lurking in a Discord server. While these activities fall at different points on the COI spectrum, they are generally of low concern as long as the standard guidelines are followed.		This is similar to the case of financial contributors, but with even more independence and flexibility. Community involvement can vary widely, from contributing content and attending events to simply lurking in a Discord server. While these activities fall at different points on the COI spectrum, they are generally of low concern as long as the standard guidelines are followed.

			<!--T:15-->
	==== Having a strong interest in a project ====		==== Having a strong interest in a project ====
	Having a general interest in a topic or project is '''not considered a COI and is, in fact, encouraged'''! The Wiki is built on contributions from volunteers who share their time and expertise. While we value those who contribute to any page that needs it, we also encourage editors to focus on topics they are passionate about, as long as they do so in a responsible and balanced manner.		Having a general interest in a topic or project is '''not considered a COI and is, in fact, encouraged'''! The Wiki is built on contributions from volunteers who share their time and expertise. While we value those who contribute to any page that needs it, we also encourage editors to focus on topics they are passionate about, as long as they do so in a responsible and balanced manner.
	</translate>		</translate>
	<translate>		<translate>
			<!--T:16-->
	== A general example that summarizes it all: ==		== A general example that summarizes it all: ==
	Let's assume a hypothetical project in the form of a World called "'''Super Fun World'''".		Let's assume a hypothetical project in the form of a World called "'''Super Fun World'''".
Line 55:		Line 71:
	</translate>		</translate>
	<translate>		<translate>
			<!--T:17-->
	==Conflict of Interest noticebox==		==Conflict of Interest noticebox==
	If an article primarily (or entirely) contains content written by someone with a '''partial''' Conflict of Interest, it will be displayed with the following noticebox:		If an article primarily (or entirely) contains content written by someone with a '''partial''' Conflict of Interest, it will be displayed with the following noticebox:
	{{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}}		{{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}}

			<!--T:18-->
	Note, this '''cannot''' be used to circumvent the two fundamental policies. Any pages found to have been created in violation of them, ''even if they contain this noticebox'', will still be eligible for deletion.		Note, this '''cannot''' be used to circumvent the two fundamental policies. Any pages found to have been created in violation of them, ''even if they contain this noticebox'', will still be eligible for deletion.

			<!--T:19-->
	It can be added to to an article using the following text: <nowiki>{{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}}</nowiki>		It can be added to to an article using the following text: <nowiki>{{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}}</nowiki>
	</translate>		</translate>
	<translate>		<translate>
			<!--T:20-->
	==See also==		==See also==
	* [[VRCWiki:Guidelines\|VRCWiki:Guidelines]]		* [[VRCWiki:Guidelines\|VRCWiki:Guidelines]]

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:13, 13 January 2025
Line 2:		Line 2:
	<translate>		<translate>
	'''Conflict of Interest (COI)''' occurs when an individual has significant affiliations with a project, such as a [[Special:MyLanguage/Worlds\|World]], Avatar, Prefab, or Community. COI editing refers to the practice of someone closely associated with a project creating or making substantial edits to a page about that project.		'''Conflict of Interest (COI)''' occurs when an individual has significant affiliations with a project, such as a [[Special:MyLanguage/Worlds\|World]], Avatar, Prefab, or Community. COI editing refers to the practice of someone closely associated with a project creating or making substantial edits to a page about that project.
	~~</translate>~~
	~~<translate>~~
	Conflict of Interest is best understood not as a standalone policy but as part of the broader framework of general editor guidelines, alongside principles like [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Notability\|Notability]], [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Neutral point of view\|Neutral Point of View (NPOV)]], and [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research\|No Original Research (NOR)]]. COI policies work in conjunction with these guidelines to preemptively avoid potential issues before any edits are made. For instance, Notability cannot be self-established, and COI policies reinforce this by preventing individuals or organizations from establishing the Notability of their own projects through page creation.		Conflict of Interest is best understood not as a standalone policy but as part of the broader framework of general editor guidelines, alongside principles like [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Notability\|Notability]], [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Neutral point of view\|Neutral Point of View (NPOV)]], and [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research\|No Original Research (NOR)]]. COI policies work in conjunction with these guidelines to preemptively avoid potential issues before any edits are made. For instance, Notability cannot be self-established, and COI policies reinforce this by preventing individuals or organizations from establishing the Notability of their own projects through page creation.

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:12, 13 January 2025
Line 1:		Line 1:
	'''Conflict of Interest (COI)''' occurs when an individual has significant affiliations with a project, such as a [[Worlds\|World]], Avatar, Prefab, or Community. COI editing refers to the practice of someone closely associated with a project creating or making substantial edits to a page about that project.		<languages/>
			<translate>
	Conflict of Interest is best understood not as a standalone policy but as part of the broader framework of general editor guidelines, alongside principles like [[VRCWiki:Notability\|Notability]], [[VRCWiki:Neutral point of view\|Neutral Point of View (NPOV)]], and [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research\|No Original Research (NOR)]]. COI policies work in conjunction with these guidelines to preemptively avoid potential issues before any edits are made. For instance, Notability cannot be self-established, and COI policies reinforce this by preventing individuals or organizations from establishing the Notability of their own projects through page creation.		'''Conflict of Interest (COI)''' occurs when an individual has significant affiliations with a project, such as a [[Special:MyLanguage/Worlds\|World]], Avatar, Prefab, or Community. COI editing refers to the practice of someone closely associated with a project creating or making substantial edits to a page about that project.
			</translate>
			<translate>
			Conflict of Interest is best understood not as a standalone policy but as part of the broader framework of general editor guidelines, alongside principles like [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Notability\|Notability]], [[Special:MyLanguage/VRCWiki:Neutral point of view\|Neutral Point of View (NPOV)]], and [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research\|No Original Research (NOR)]]. COI policies work in conjunction with these guidelines to preemptively avoid potential issues before any edits are made. For instance, Notability cannot be self-established, and COI policies reinforce this by preventing individuals or organizations from establishing the Notability of their own projects through page creation.

	It is not assumed that an editor with a COI would create or edit a page with the intention of advertising. However, an editor with a COI is inherently more likely to embellish information, selectively curate content, or [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research\|treat the page as a primary source]].		It is not assumed that an editor with a COI would create or edit a page with the intention of advertising. However, an editor with a COI is inherently more likely to embellish information, selectively curate content, or [[wikipedia:Wikipedia:No_original_research\|treat the page as a primary source]].
			</translate>
			<translate>
	== Examples ==		== Examples ==
	Here are some examples of situations where you would have a Conflict of Interest for a given project:		Here are some examples of situations where you would have a Conflict of Interest for a given project:
Line 11:		Line 15:
	* You were involved in developing, moderating, or facilitating the project in any tangible way.		* You were involved in developing, moderating, or facilitating the project in any tangible way.
	* You were the sole or initial financial backer of the project (e.g., commissioning the project).		* You were the sole or initial financial backer of the project (e.g., commissioning the project).
			</translate>
			<translate>
	== Policies ==		== Policies ==
	The VRChat Wiki enforces '''two core policies''' regarding Conflict of Interest editing:		The VRChat Wiki enforces '''two core policies''' regarding Conflict of Interest editing:
Line 17:		Line 22:
	# '''Restrictions on Editing''': Editors who have created a project or made significant contributions to it are strictly prohibited from creating pages about that project. Editors with a substantial COI are limited to making only [[wikipedia:Help:Minor_edit\|minor edits]] on pages related to the project.		# '''Restrictions on Editing''': Editors who have created a project or made significant contributions to it are strictly prohibited from creating pages about that project. Editors with a substantial COI are limited to making only [[wikipedia:Help:Minor_edit\|minor edits]] on pages related to the project.
	# '''Enforcement and Consequences''': Pages created in violation of these policies are subject to immediate deletion, with the author being notified through appropriate channels, such as their talk page or Discord (if applicable).		# '''Enforcement and Consequences''': Pages created in violation of these policies are subject to immediate deletion, with the author being notified through appropriate channels, such as their talk page or Discord (if applicable).
			</translate>
			<translate>
	== Situations that are ''NOT'' (necessarily) Conflicts of Interest ==		== Situations that are ''NOT'' (necessarily) Conflicts of Interest ==
	Conflict of Interest is not always a clear-cut, binary concept but rather a spectrum of proximity and involvement. When an editor with even a slight affiliation to a project considers their potential COI, it is generally wise to err on the side of caution and assume a COI exists to avoid any potential conflicts. However, there are many situations where someone with a potential COI can still make constructive major edits to a project's page, depending on various factors.		Conflict of Interest is not always a clear-cut, binary concept but rather a spectrum of proximity and involvement. When an editor with even a slight affiliation to a project considers their potential COI, it is generally wise to err on the side of caution and assume a COI exists to avoid any potential conflicts. However, there are many situations where someone with a potential COI can still make constructive major edits to a project's page, depending on various factors.
Line 38:		Line 44:
	==== Having a strong interest in a project ====		==== Having a strong interest in a project ====
	Having a general interest in a topic or project is '''not considered a COI and is, in fact, encouraged'''! The Wiki is built on contributions from volunteers who share their time and expertise. While we value those who contribute to any page that needs it, we also encourage editors to focus on topics they are passionate about, as long as they do so in a responsible and balanced manner.		Having a general interest in a topic or project is '''not considered a COI and is, in fact, encouraged'''! The Wiki is built on contributions from volunteers who share their time and expertise. While we value those who contribute to any page that needs it, we also encourage editors to focus on topics they are passionate about, as long as they do so in a responsible and balanced manner.
			</translate>
			<translate>
	== A general example that summarizes it all: ==		== A general example that summarizes it all: ==
	Let's assume a hypothetical project in the form of a World called "'''Super Fun World'''".		Let's assume a hypothetical project in the form of a World called "'''Super Fun World'''".
Line 47:		Line 54:
	* A '''hardcore fan''' of Super Fun World reads a new development blog published by the creator and decides some of the information is notable enough to include in the article. They add a new section (or update an existing one) with a neutral point of view, using the blog as a citation.		* A '''hardcore fan''' of Super Fun World reads a new development blog published by the creator and decides some of the information is notable enough to include in the article. They add a new section (or update an existing one) with a neutral point of view, using the blog as a citation.
	…and so on! This example illustrates how different levels of affiliation affect editing practices while ensuring adherence to COI guidelines.		…and so on! This example illustrates how different levels of affiliation affect editing practices while ensuring adherence to COI guidelines.
			</translate>
			<translate>
	==Conflict of Interest noticebox==		==Conflict of Interest noticebox==
	If an article primarily (or entirely) contains content written by someone with a '''partial''' Conflict of Interest, it will be displayed with the following noticebox:		If an article primarily (or entirely) contains content written by someone with a '''partial''' Conflict of Interest, it will be displayed with the following noticebox:
Line 55:		Line 63:

	It can be added to to an article using the following text: <nowiki>{{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}}</nowiki>		It can be added to to an article using the following text: <nowiki>{{Noticebox/Conflict of interest}}</nowiki>
			</translate>
			<translate>
	==See also==		==See also==
	* [[VRCWiki:Guidelines]]		* [[VRCWiki:Guidelines\|VRCWiki:Guidelines]]
	* [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Conflict_of_interest Wikipedia:Conflict of interest] on Wikipedia		* [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Conflict_of_interest Wikipedia:Conflict of interest] on Wikipedia
			</translate>
	[[Category:VRCWiki policies]]		[[Category:VRCWiki policies{{#translation:}}]]

← Older revision	Revision as of 01:11, 13 January 2025
(No difference)

← Older revision	Revision as of 17:51, 8 October 2024
(No difference)

VRCWiki:Conflicts of interest - Revision history

Usr 2c0d9735-9342-4db3-9c48-5eb152581b08: Add English Original Rules

Usr c0fd3826-5fbd-465b-869b-142f974af714: Added policy navbox & added around a copy+paste string.

Usr 2c0d9735-9342-4db3-9c48-5eb152581b08: Changed protection settings for "VRCWiki:Conflicts of interest": changed back ([Edit=Allow only administrators] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite))

Usr 2c0d9735-9342-4db3-9c48-5eb152581b08: Marked this version for translation

Usr 2c0d9735-9342-4db3-9c48-5eb152581b08: Fix group

Usr 2c0d9735-9342-4db3-9c48-5eb152581b08: Mark for Translation

Usr 2c0d9735-9342-4db3-9c48-5eb152581b08: Changed protection settings for "VRCWiki:Conflicts of interest": temp change to mark for translation ([Edit=Allow only autoconfirmed users] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only autoconfirmed users] (indefinite))

Usr 578aa632-439b-4c41-9266-776323ba9ad2: de-tableify wording while maintaining intent (needs proofread!)

Usr c272d4fe-f1f8-4d77-8008-cad6cb81d6cd: Protected "VRCWiki:Conflicts of interest": High-risk template or module: This is a VRCWiki policy page and should not be edited by regular editors. ([Edit=Allow only administrators] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite))

Usr c0fd3826-5fbd-465b-869b-142f974af714: Added policy navbox & added `around a copy+paste string.`